The iPocalypse - that's what people are calling the less-than-smooth launch of the 3G iPhone. I was in Austin when it launched - several of my co-workers made the attempt to get an iPhone on launch day and returned with horror stories just like those you've read elsewhere on the net.
Beth had wanted a 3G iPhone since after I got an iPhone last year, so we agreed to wait until it was announced and then go get one shortly thereafter. Since I was out of town during the launch, we figured we'd pop yesterday (Sunday) and get one. I don't know if I can fully express my dissatisfaction with thie process so far - and that's without having attempted to wait in any lines. I'm one of those who thinks it's silly to wait in line more than 30 minutes for a phone, so I'm happy to wait it out, but still - the process this time has been markedly different than the initial launch, and a regression on so many levels that it's hard to fathom.
When the first rumors of the iPhone were throbbing through the 'net, I thought for sure it was a hoax - there's no way Apple could deliver that all-in-one experience without being beholden to one of Satan's many minions, all of whom work in the US cellular industry - an industry populated with sharks and sleaze, driven by commission and staffed by undermotivated, underpaid and undertrained staff. Wireless carriers' stated goal may not be to make your buying experience as horrific as that of buying a car, but it invariably is.
With that in mind, I was shocked and surprised to find that the first iPhone was set up in a way that allowed you to buy it in the store off the shelf and take it home, signing up for your plan and activating entirely from within iTunes - no salesmen forcing upgrades and accessories down your throat or - more likely - getting confused and mistyping/misspelling your name or giving you a plan you did not ask for or want. When the 3G iPhone was announced, it was announced that this was no longer the case - activation and setup in stores was mandatory. So there's one step backward into the morass.
When Beth's Verizon account hit its 2-year contract limit last December, she signed on with AT&T with a cheap phone and we got a family plan, thinking that when the 3G comes out, we'll upgrade. In any other industry, this would be good business. For the cellular carriers though, this has little to no bearing. As it turns out, owing to the way cell companies subsidize their phones so they can sell them cheaply, Beth will have to pay $499 to get a 16GB iPhone. Had she remained a Verizon customer up until now and switched fresh, she'd merely pay $299 for the phone and the privilege of joining AT&T's family. It's actively customer-hostile owing to the oddities of subsidizing, but there it is. Of course I can upgrade to a 3G iPhone today since the original iPhone was not subsidized, but that helps us not at all.
I wonder though - canceling her line outright costs $175, which is less than the "upgrade premium" of $200. It might be cheaper by $25 to cancel and re-sign her as a new account than try to upgrade but I'm sure AT&T has done their math and added some sort of $25 "new user" fee that is not apparent.
Adding to my frustration, AT&T's wireless website seems to be flaky. I can't go 5 minutes without an error page, usually cleared up by my retrying a link. Sometimes it'll kick me off with a cryptic error about a problem with my login session. This happens on 2 different computers. Also, god help you if you have 2 lines and want to add the second line to a family plan. You'll be greeted with a web page with instructions that tell you in no uncertain terms that the process is broken and they apologize for it not working. That'd be fine if it was a short-term glitch but this has persisted ever since Beth switched. The cost to us is negligible so it hasn't been worth pursuing, but the ballsy way it has stayed broken is something else.
We did call around to local AT&T stores yesterday to check on availability. None had any in stock. Some offered to "special order" the phone and get back to us. Some stores gave conflicting information about availability. Owing to the odd restrictions in place on plans, we are forced to buy from an AT&T store rather than the Apple store. There are some truly amazing horror stories about AT&T customer service from brave souls who have gone further than we have on the macrumors.com forums.
All in all, given the chance I'd move away from AT&T in a heartbeat if the iPhone were on any US competitor. I can see other companies being as bad, but the bar is set pretty low right now - it's hard to imagine worse.